MATESHIP WITH BIRDS
by Carrie Tiffany
Reviewed by Judy Lim
In 1922 Alec Chisholm, a bird lover and naturalist, wrote about the birds he watched and called
his book Mateship with Birds. His book is delightfully easy to read, humorous and insightful.
In 2012 Carrie Tiffany, a former park ranger and currently an agricultural journalist, has written
an equally delightful book whose title she has taken from Chisholm's work. In Tiffany's version however,
she writes primarily about a small group of people living near the township of Cohuna in an isolated
farming district in northern Victoria, Australia, in the early 1950s.
Harry is a dairy farmer who has lost his wife to the charms of a local bird watcher. He has no
children and lives alone, with a pile of women's journals, his routines and his thoughts, which
often turn to the young family living next door. Betty is a single mother who works at the
nursing home in town. She has two children: Michael, a young teenager, who goes to school,
helps around the farm and thinks a lot about girls; and little Hazel who has never known her
father yet has always known Harry.
Betty is a lonely woman, but she "gets on with the day for there is nothing else to be done with it."
She is a pragmatic person who tends to her charges at the nursing home with love and respect. She
yearns for love, perhaps even for some romance, but being the humble woman she is, does not
imagine that she will ever be fortunate enough to be desired by another man.
Mateship with Birds is a book about observation, about observing the world through its
seasons, its landscape and through nature. Although Harry observes all aspects of nature, he has
a special affinity for the birds on his property. He watches a family of kookaburras, wondering
at their ability to be both loving and cruel yet still remain a family, and causing Harry to
speculate about how his own family compared to that of the kookaburras.
Even the farm is almost a character in this sparse and unsentimental story with an undercurrent
of desire and love. Every aspect of birth, life, death and decay as seen on the farm by Harry and
the children is discussed or at least mentioned in Tiffany's uncompromising style. However, when
Harry, in his usual earnest way, attempts to aid Michael in his transition from boy to man by
writing letters discussing sex, he finds himself in trouble. He has neglected to talk to Betty
about what he is doing and she is not happy.
Mateship with Birds is a quiet book. It includes passages of field notes and journal
entries which read at times like a scrapbook or ledger of the life Harry, Betty and the children
have on the land. The language is practical, even sometimes hard and pragmatic. Yet through
Tiffany's ability to compare and contrast the landscape and nature to her characters, it remains
tender, sensitive and intimate. Tiffany's elegant prose has produced a quirky book which is
endearing, surprising and charmingly readable.